Brisbane Broncos Face Retention Battle as Xavier Willison Heads to Open Market
The Brisbane Broncos are facing a nervous wait to retain star prop Xavier Willison as the 24-year-old prepares to test the open market on November 1. Although Brisbane has put forward a four-year extension offer worth $1 million per season—viewing him as the eventual successor to lead their pack like Payne Haas—former Test forward James Graham has argued that the deal is actually a "bargain" for the club rather than an overpay.
This article was prepared with AI assistance based on supplied news reporting and commentary regarding player contract negotiations and market valuations.
The Contract Stand-Off and Market Value
Just weeks ago, the Broncos expressed strong confidence that Willison would re-sign before rival clubs could legally enter discussions. However, Willison and his management confirmed he will explore external offers as reported by Fox Sports.
Willison's stock has risen significantly after he was awarded the Paul Morgan Medal as Brisbane’s best player for 2026. He is also currently part of the New Zealand squad at the World Cup.
Speaking on his Bye Round podcast, James Graham—who played 392 first-grade games across the NRL and Super League—suggested that rival clubs could easily push past Brisbane's offer.
"They’re desperate. They can’t afford to lose him," Graham said. He noted that other clubs could scale up bids by 25 percent to reach $1.25 million per season to secure Willison as an alpha forward during his absolute peak years.
Weighing Long-Term Security Versus Shorter Deals
Graham also raised questions about whether a four-year commitment is ideal for a player of Willison's age. At 24, signing a long-term deal provides financial security, but it locks in rates that might fall below market value as the player hits his prime.
"Maybe you’d look and go, do you get a two-year deal and back yourself to be the best front rower?" Graham said, pointing out that players typically sacrifice wiggle room when trading years for long-term certainty.
Historically, paying forwards upwards of $1 million per season has carried mixed results across the NRL. Notable past examples include:
* Jason Taumalolo (2017): Signed a monster 10-year, $10 million deal with the North Queensland Cowboys as confirmed by Fox Sports when he was running for more than 200 meters per game, which was considered astronomical money at the time to lock down long-term value.
* David Fifita (2020): Left the Broncos for the Gold Coast Titans on a three-year contract worth more than $3 million, though he subsequently battled indifferent form.
Emerging Threats to Brisbane
Competition for Willison's signature extends beyond traditional NRL clubs. The Papua New Guinea (PNG) Chiefs loom as a major threat to Brisbane's retention efforts.
According to reports, if the PNG Chiefs match a $1 million per season offer from the Broncos, tax-free breaks offered in PNG would effectively net Willison an extra $560,000 a season, presenting a distinct financial incentive alongside rival clubs eager to bid for his services.